Comparison of Advantages Between European-Style Cranes and Traditional Cranes

Comparison of main beam structures:

The main beam of the European-style crane features a box-girder structure, which is both structurally sound and offers superior rigidity and strength. The hoist is securely integrated with the lower flange of the main beam, ensuring complete safety with no potential hazards. This design also maximizes the effective lifting space, thereby enhancing the overall operational workspace—resulting in a maximum clear headroom that can reach up to 1.5 Rice, wheel pressure decreases, and rail support beams are reduced.

Traditional cranes, limited by their hoists and design, can only utilize conventional bottom-mounted I-steel structures—structures that are inherently inefficient and underutilized. Moreover, the way the hoist is connected to the lower flange of the main beam significantly increases the risk of detachment accidents.

Space Cost Comparison:

European-style cranes feature a sleek, elegant design that aligns perfectly with modern industrial aesthetics. They efficiently maximize factory space, with the hook positioned at minimal distance from both side walls and requiring low headroom—allowing for greater flexibility in existing facility layouts. Meanwhile, new factory designs can be more compact yet still pack in all the necessary functionality.

Traditional cranes have a bulky, cumbersome appearance, with large horizontal and vertical dimensions that result in a small effective working area, leading to low space utilization within the same factory structure.

European-style cranes feature a small clearance height and lightweight design. They boast a compact structure, minimal self-weight, excellent wind resistance, smooth operation, and reliable safety—making them an ideal choice for various applications.

Traditional cranes require large amounts of steel, are bulky, and come with high construction costs.

Security Level Comparison:

European-style cranes feature a high protection rating, rapid heat dissipation, and an extended service life. With their fully enclosed design, they prevent dust accumulation, while variable-frequency speed control ensures safer operation.

Traditional cranes operate at a single speed, resulting in significant impact and causing heavy loads to swing violently. Their reduction mechanisms are open-style, leaving them exposed to the elements.

Comparison of Operation and Maintenance Costs:

European-style cranes feature low overall power consumption and are energy-efficient. They boast reliable quality, with a low failure rate under normal use—minimizing downtime losses caused by equipment malfunctions while also helping to cut down on costly equipment maintenance expenses.

Traditional cranes have high overall power consumption, leading to significant electricity usage and operational costs. During operation, limitations in cost often result in shorter lifespans for components, higher failure rates, and increased risks of production downtime—as well as additional expenses for repairs and part replacements.